Colonial Pantry Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Colonial Pantry, an old-fashioned deli nestled in Mendham, NJ, where quality meets tradition. With a delightful array of sandwiches and premium meats, this deli stands out as a true gem among local eateries.

Highlighting their commitment to freshness, Colonial Pantry serves sandwiches piled high with flavorful ingredients. Signature offerings include delicious Italian subs featuring Genoa salami and capacola, and unbeatable options like turkey and roast beef sandwiches, all on exceptional homemade bread from Hoboken.

• Favorites include the chili, renowned for its rich flavor.
• They also offer delightful deli items, such as boiled ham and Swiss cheese.
• Superb customer service ensures each sandwich can be customized to your liking.

With a legacy of 50 years and a loyal clientele, Colonial Pantry embodies everything a deli should be: inviting, flavorful, and full of heart.