Welcome to Colonial Pantry
At Colonial Pantry, nestled in Mendham, NJ, we embrace a rich tradition of quality deli offerings that have delighted customers for over 50 years. Run by a dedicated father-son duo, our hallmark lies in fresh, homemade sandwiches crafted with premium meats and artisan bread from Hoboken. Popular selections include the delectable Italian subs and hearty Reubens, each meticulously made to reflect our commitment to quality and care. Customers rave not just about our delicious fare but also the warmth of our service. At Colonial Pantry, every meal is a celebration of flavor and community, making it a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike.
-
5 W Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945 Hotline: (973) 543-4600
Welcome to Colonial Pantry, a cherished gem nestled at 5 W Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945. This old-fashioned deli, with its warm atmosphere and friendly service, has proudly served the Mendham community for over 50 years. A family-run establishment, it is operated by two passionate gentlemen, Sam and Rick, who pour their hearts into every sandwich.
At Colonial Pantry, the spotlight shines on their artisanal sandwiches. Customers rave about the Italian sub, crafted with premium meats and served on incredible bread sourced from Hoboken. Each bite resonates with flavor, encapsulating the essence of a truly great deli. As Phillip W. notes, they use "excellent bread" and "premium meats," making the trip to this deli worthwhile for any sandwich lover.
- Popular Sandwiches:
- Tunafish Salad
- Egg Salad
- Bologna and Cheese
- Chicken Salad
- Lobster Salad
- Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese
- Hot Meat Loaf
- Specialty Meats:
- Genoa Salami, Capicola, Provolone ($7.95)
- Turkey, Roast Beef ($7.45)
- Boiled Ham, Capicola, Provolone ($7.95)
- Pepperoni, Provolone ($6.95)
Many patrons, including Mary J. and John R., extol the virtues of Colonial Pantry’s cold subs, noting their exceptional flavor and consistent quality. The commitment to using whole, homemade ingredients without artificial additions means that every meal is a wholesome experience. The meats are farm-fresh, a fact that truly resonates with their loyal clientele.
Beyond sandwiches, Colonial Pantry also offers a selection of local farm products, including steaks and honey, showcasing the best of regional flavors. Each meal reflects the dedication and care that Rick and Sam put into their craft, as noted by Mark T. and Allie L., who also appreciate the deli's welcoming environment and friendly service.
Colonial Pantry isn’t just a deli; it’s a community hub where the quality and consistency of the food speak volumes. With positive reviews from local patrons like Brent W. and Bill H., it’s clear that every visit brings joy and satisfaction. If you’re searching for a great sandwich or a slice of Mendham’s rich culinary history, look no further than Colonial Pantry. Stop by and enjoy a sandwich that is genuinely made with love!
Excellent bread, premium meats. Great sub shop, worth a drive. Italian subs are great. Super roast beef. They are happy to customize!
Been here few times, their cold subs are always delicious, especially the turkey and beef
this old-fashioned deli is run by 2 fine gentlman. Their food is whole, homemade nothing artificial. The meats are farm fresh. do you know they have been there 50 years that speak about how great the business is and how good the food is
we've lived about a 15 minute walk away for over 27 years. this place has never gone down in quality. my son grew up loving the Reuben's and now lives in CA and still heads there for a Reuben whenever he comes home. It's his first food stop on his eating tour of NJ every trip. Honestly, every sandwich we've had is fantastic and good value in a small, overpriced town. Impressed with the consistency. It isn't fancy but the quality is there.
Love this place. I've been getting sandwiches from here for over a decade. Small family business. The thing that sets their sandwiches apart is the bread from Hoboken. Great Italian bread. Not soft and fluffy. I'm
Great sandwich shop that also has items from their local farm; great steaks and honey. Rick & Sam take the time to make each meal a reflection of them- quality and care. Enjoy.
Super friendly owners and delicious food!!! We love this deli and their sandwiches. Their other products are also wonderful--we bought the strawberry wine and it is the best wine I have ever had. Ever.
I don't review much I'm not the type But hands down great deli .. Been going here for 5 years everything is fresh I've ordered one of everything on the menu it's all excellent! Sam and Rick are great !
I've been in 3-4 times since we moved to Mendham a little while ago and have enjoyed it each and every time. It's run by a great, friendly father and son team. Everything is fresh, with some items from a nearby farm and even some butchering on site. If you want a great, humongous sandwich, this is the place, especially their Italian sandwiches. They're made with awesome bread and piled high with meat and cheese. A whole one is easily enough for two. They are also famous for their chili, which is also excellent. Overall, if you are hungry for a great sandwich, definitely stop here!